Difference between revisions of "Talk:Admission to studies"

From Hindupedia, the Hindu Encyclopedia
 
(17 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
We shall now take up the subject of the considerations that governed admission to medical studies. We give below an exhaustive list of the qualifications required in a student of medicine and it is clear from its perusal that as much importance was attached to moral fitness as to physical and intellectual fitness. In face the insistence on moral fitness was the greatest as can be seen from the fact that the vast majority of the required qualifications concern the ethical side of the student's personality. This insistence which is generally absent to-day, and the elaborateness with which it was set out in ancient days was no doubt due to the consideration that moral excellence is the very basis of all true education. But this is less readily ascertainable than intellectual and physical worth. This probably is the reason why moral fitness in students has gradually tended to be ignored, although the general decline in the standards of public and private morality cannot be denied its share. We should remember in this connection that the aim of all education, including medical education, was not to enable the student to earn a livelihood so much as to inculcate in him a love for the good life. As regards the practical difficulties in ascertaining whether a student had the necessary moral equipment, they did not exist, as under the ancient system of Gurukula education, the relation between the teacher and the pupil was as intimate as that between the father and the son. In fact, during the entire period of education the teacher was actually in the place of the father, the pupil being fed, clothed and housed by him. Thus two of the most common names for a "Sisya" or a student are "Antevasin" and 'Chatra' and both denote this intimate association, while the word "Acarya" signifies that his primary business was in help�ing his pupils to develop a sound character.
+
In ancient times, there was a long list of qualifications required in a student to get admission in a university for the study of medicine. Moral, physical and intellectual fitness were given consideration. Of the three, moral fitness was most important because the majority of the pre-requisite qualifications were concerned with ethics.  
  
 
+
The aim of education in ancient times, including medical education, was to inculcate in the student a love for life and not just enable them to earn a livelihood.  This aim could not be achieved if students did not have good ethics as a base upon which the rest of education was built upon.
  
Great care was taken to see that no undesirable candidate got admission to studies. The universities of Vikramaditya, in the words of the Chinese traveller, were guarded scrupulously by the most erudite of scholars who held the examination for admission which was difficult to pass The members of this admission committee were aptly called �Dwara Panditas� whose business was to see that the standard of the University�s scholarship was not lowered by the invasion of mediocrity.
+
==Ancient Synopsis==
 +
'''I don't understand how the first line connects to the Gurukula system described in this paragraph'''
 +
Regarding the practical difficulties in ascertaining whether a student was morally acceptable or not had the necessary moral equipment, as under the ancient system of Gurukula education, the relation between the teacher and the pupil was as intimate as that between the father and the son. In fact, during the entire period of education the teacher was actually in the place of the father, the pupil being fed, clothed and housed by him. Thus two of the most common names for a "Sisyā"; or a student are "Antevāsin" and 'Chātra' and both denote this intimate association, while the word "Ācārya" signifies that his primary business was in helping his pupils to develop a sound character.
  
 
+
==Entrance Procedures==
 +
Great care was taken to see that no undesirable candidate got admission to studies. The universities of Vikramaditya, in the words of the Chinese traveler '''is his name mentioned?''',
  
That such strict selection was most important is seen from Caraka�s statement that "knowledge like a sword or water requires a clean repository".
 
  
''''Weapons, learning and water are wholly dependent for their merits or demerits on their holder".
+
'''I can't understand the following paragraph'''
 +
was having the most erudite scholars who held the examination for admission which was difficult to pass.  
  
 
 
  
As a result only two of three of them could have admission for studies. If the person possessing knowledge is unworthy of it, it is worse than useless and it is fraught with danger. It was accordingly prescribed that before a prospective student was admitted to studies, he had to undergo a period of probation which extended from six months to one year. Thus we find Vagbhata saying in the Astanga Sangraha that it is only after the teacher has been fully satisfied of the character and worth of the candidates that the actual schooling should begin and this schooling once begun should continue till the student had mastered the subject both in theory and practice.
+
The members of this admission committee were aptly called Dwāra Panditas whose business was to see that the standard of the University's scholarship was not lowered by any influences. That such strict selection was most important is seen from Caraka's statement:
 +
<blockquote>"Knowledge like a sword or water requires a clean repository.
 +
Weapons, learning and water are wholly dependent for their merits or demerits on their holder."</blockquote>
  
''�''A disciple who is capable and possessed of modesty, purity and arts and who has served a probationary period of six months, should be taught as long as he gains perfection in the theory and practice of the science.
+
==Probation Period==
 +
As a result only two or three of them could have admission for studies. If the person possessing knowledge is unworthy of it, it is worse than useless and it is dangerous too. It was accordingly prescribed that before a prospective student was admitted to studies, he had to undergo a period of probation which extended from six months to one year. Thus we find
  
 
+
'''Vagbhata?'''
 +
Vagbhata saying in the Astanga Sangraha, that it is only after the teacher has been fully satisfied of the character and worth of the candidates that the actual schooling should begin and that this schooling should continue till the student had mastered the subject in theory and in practice.
  
Thus the danger of morally unworthy persons acquiring the power that comes through knowledge as well as the danger of incompetent or half-baked practitioners being let loose upon society are avoided. The system of probationary studentship, it should be pointed out, is not altogether absent in modern education; it obtains in certain western universities though the rules governing such probationership are neither so stringent nor so complete as those which obtained in the medical institutions of ancient India.
+
==Qualities Required in a Discipline==
 +
A disciple who is capable and possessed of modesty, purity and arts and who has served a probationary period of six months, should be taught as long as he gains perfection in the theory and practice of the science. Thus the possibility of any morally unworthy persons or any incompetent practitioners acquiring the knowledge of medicine is avoided. The system of probationary studentship is not altogether absent in modern education; it exists in certain western universities though the rules governing such probation period are neither so stringent nor so complete compared to those in the medical institutions of ancient India.
  
 
 
  
It is true that considerations of the caste and lineage of the candidate played an important role in the determination of his admission for the studies contemplated, but even here the under�lying factor was purely one of moral worth. Thus in the famous story of Satyakama, the sou of a serving woman, the teacher is confronted with the problem of deciding the eligibility of the boy who is unable to provide him with a Gotra or paternal lineage but who is otherwise eminently fitted for the life of a student. The teacher concerned, who is no less a person than Uddalaka Aruni decides that no one who was not a Brahmana could tell the truth so boldly as Satyakama and accor�dingly commands him to fetch wood for the sacrificial fire, a token that he has been admitted to studentship.
+
Jati and lineage were used as an underlying factor to evaluate a prospective student's moral worth. For example, in the well-known story of Satyakama, the son of a serving woman, the teacher, Uddalaka Aruni, is confused as to the eligibility of Satyakama to study under his tutelage because Satyakama is unable to provide any information on his Gotra or paternal lineage but otherwise seems eminently eligible to study under him. Despite this, Uddalaka decides to admin Satyakama because Satyakama was upfront and honest about his questionable paternal lineage.  Uddalaka felt that no one would tell the truth as boldly as Satyakama and hence commanded him to fetch wood for the sacrificial fire, a token signifying that he has accepted him as his student.
  
 
+
==Criteria for study of Ayurveda==
 +
By whom should Ayurveda be studied?
  
It is clear from this story related in the Chandogya Upanisad that only Brahmanas were normally received as student by the great teachers of the day. This privileged position of the Brahmana in the sphere of learning continued for long, but in the course of tune, Ksatriyas and Vaisyas were admitted in incr�easing numbers into what had been a jealously guarded preserve of the Brahmanas, and later even the Sudra as mentioned in Susruta and Kasyapa was considered eligible.
+
Ayurveda could be studied by members of any varna: Brahmanas, Ksatriyas, Vaisyas or Sudras.  Preferential treatment was given, however, to the students belonging to a family of medical practitioners as it was understood that such association from childhood would lead to a better aptitude for medical learning and practice than one who is from non-medical family<ref> In support of this statement, Dr R. K Mookerjee says in his "Ancient Indian education" that Social psychology has proved that every individual has his own set of emotions, action attitudes and ways of thinking, which is the gift of the traditions and social environment in which he is brought up. Each segment of training must therefore take into account the concrete individuals, a product of biological gifts and social heritage. A neglect of this basic situation renders the process of education less fruitful and sometimes even more risky to the personality.</ref><ref>The investigation of Haggerty, Nash and Goodenough show further that the educational status and vocation of the parents have a significant correlation with the level of capacity of the children as indicated by the intelligence quotient. For instance, the children of professional parents of those of a higher academic standing possess a higher value of I. Q on a whole.</ref>
  
 
+
Two of the requirements, both connected with the morality of the student, may however be noticed in passing. These are:
 +
# Brahmacarya
 +
# Jitendriyatwa
  
''�''Some say that one should coach up even a Sudra possessed of good lineage and qualities withholding the instruction of Mantras and also the sacred thread�.
+
Both are important qualities in the life of a student. A student is expected to be dedicated to the pursuit of knowledge and should therefore be able to turn his or her back on all sense-pleasures in the manner of the boy Naciketas, who when tempted by king Yama to give up his pursuit of the Truth said:
 +
<blockquote>Keep thou thy chariots, thy dancing girls and singing; I will have none of them.</blockquote>
  
 
+
It is only then that the great king Yama considered him worthy of being taught, saying:
  
''�'' By whom should Aurveda be studied? It should be studied by Brahmanas, Ksatriyas, Vaisyas and Sudras.&quot;
+
<blockquote>I know that you Naciketas, are a true seeker of knowledge, for you resisted all the temptations I put before you.</blockquote>
  
 
+
==Conclusion==
 +
It is clear from the story in the Chandogya Upanisad that Brahmanas were given preferential treatment when it came to medical education. But in the course of time, Ksatriyas, Vaisyas and Sudras were admitted in increasing numbers<ref>Susruta and Kashyapa Samhita denote that later on even the worthy and eligible Sudras were given admissions in the schools.
  
This gradual enlargement of what we may call the educational franchise was m keeping with the progress of the times.
+
'''where is this quote from?'''
 +
<blockquote>''Some say that one should coach up even a Sudra possessed of good lineage and qualities withholding the instruction of Mantras and also the sacred thread.</blockquote>
 +
</ref>
 +
==References==
 +
{{reflist}}
  
 
+
* The Caraka Samhita published by Shree Gulabkunverba Ayurvedic Society, Jamnagar, India
 
+
There is everything in favour of a specialized learning such as medicine and surgery being imparted to members of families with long medical traditions rather than to others. This was the practice in ancient India, a practice which derived its sanction form considerations of heredity and home environment. It was believed that one belonging to a medical family would have a better aptitude for medical learning and practice than one who is from non-medical family.
+
 
+
 
+
 
+
In support of this statement Dr R. K Mookerjee says in his ancient Indian education that 'Social psychology has proved that every individual has his own equipment of emotions, action attitudes and ways of thinking, which is the gift of the traditions and social environment in which he is brought up�.
+
 
+
 
+
 
+
Each scheme of training must therefore take into account the concrete individual, a product of biological gifts and social heritage. A neglect of this basic situation renders the process of education less fruitful and sometimes even risky to the personality.
+
 
+
 
+
 
+
The investigation of Haggerty, Nash and Goodenough show further that the educational status and vocation of the parents have a significant correlation with the level of capacity of the children as indicated by the intelligence quotient. For instance, the children of professional parents of those of a higher academic standing possess, on the whole, a higher value of I. Q. The implication of such facts cannot be ignored in schemes of national education.
+
 
+
It is neither necessary nor indeed possible here to comment on all desiderata, item by item. Two of the requirements, both connected with the moral equipment of the student, may however be noticed in passing. These are Brahmacarya and Jitendriyatwa and both are qualities whose importance in the life of a student cannot be over-emphasised. The life of one who is following the pursuit of learning is a dedicated one and the votary of knowledge should therefore be able to turn his back on all sense-pleasures in the manner of the boy Naciketas, who when tempted by king Yama to give up his determination to seek the truth said, &quot;Keep thou thy chariots, thy dancing girls and singing; I will have none of them.&quot; It is then and then only that the great king of the the Dead considered him worthy of being taught, saying:
+
 
+
� I know that you Naciketas, are a true seeker after knowledge, for you resisted all the temptations I put before you.&quot;
+
 
+
 
+
  
 
[[Category:Ayurveda]][[Category:Charak Samhita]]
 
[[Category:Ayurveda]][[Category:Charak Samhita]]
 
 
 

Latest revision as of 19:03, 5 April 2019

In ancient times, there was a long list of qualifications required in a student to get admission in a university for the study of medicine. Moral, physical and intellectual fitness were given consideration. Of the three, moral fitness was most important because the majority of the pre-requisite qualifications were concerned with ethics.

The aim of education in ancient times, including medical education, was to inculcate in the student a love for life and not just enable them to earn a livelihood. This aim could not be achieved if students did not have good ethics as a base upon which the rest of education was built upon.

Ancient Synopsis

I don't understand how the first line connects to the Gurukula system described in this paragraph Regarding the practical difficulties in ascertaining whether a student was morally acceptable or not had the necessary moral equipment, as under the ancient system of Gurukula education, the relation between the teacher and the pupil was as intimate as that between the father and the son. In fact, during the entire period of education the teacher was actually in the place of the father, the pupil being fed, clothed and housed by him. Thus two of the most common names for a "Sisyā"; or a student are "Antevāsin" and 'Chātra' and both denote this intimate association, while the word "Ācārya" signifies that his primary business was in helping his pupils to develop a sound character.

Entrance Procedures

Great care was taken to see that no undesirable candidate got admission to studies. The universities of Vikramaditya, in the words of the Chinese traveler is his name mentioned?,


I can't understand the following paragraph was having the most erudite scholars who held the examination for admission which was difficult to pass.


The members of this admission committee were aptly called Dwāra Panditas whose business was to see that the standard of the University's scholarship was not lowered by any influences. That such strict selection was most important is seen from Caraka's statement:

"Knowledge like a sword or water requires a clean repository. Weapons, learning and water are wholly dependent for their merits or demerits on their holder."

Probation Period

As a result only two or three of them could have admission for studies. If the person possessing knowledge is unworthy of it, it is worse than useless and it is dangerous too. It was accordingly prescribed that before a prospective student was admitted to studies, he had to undergo a period of probation which extended from six months to one year. Thus we find

Vagbhata? Vagbhata saying in the Astanga Sangraha, that it is only after the teacher has been fully satisfied of the character and worth of the candidates that the actual schooling should begin and that this schooling should continue till the student had mastered the subject in theory and in practice.

Qualities Required in a Discipline

A disciple who is capable and possessed of modesty, purity and arts and who has served a probationary period of six months, should be taught as long as he gains perfection in the theory and practice of the science. Thus the possibility of any morally unworthy persons or any incompetent practitioners acquiring the knowledge of medicine is avoided. The system of probationary studentship is not altogether absent in modern education; it exists in certain western universities though the rules governing such probation period are neither so stringent nor so complete compared to those in the medical institutions of ancient India.


Jati and lineage were used as an underlying factor to evaluate a prospective student's moral worth. For example, in the well-known story of Satyakama, the son of a serving woman, the teacher, Uddalaka Aruni, is confused as to the eligibility of Satyakama to study under his tutelage because Satyakama is unable to provide any information on his Gotra or paternal lineage but otherwise seems eminently eligible to study under him. Despite this, Uddalaka decides to admin Satyakama because Satyakama was upfront and honest about his questionable paternal lineage. Uddalaka felt that no one would tell the truth as boldly as Satyakama and hence commanded him to fetch wood for the sacrificial fire, a token signifying that he has accepted him as his student.

Criteria for study of Ayurveda

By whom should Ayurveda be studied?

Ayurveda could be studied by members of any varna: Brahmanas, Ksatriyas, Vaisyas or Sudras. Preferential treatment was given, however, to the students belonging to a family of medical practitioners as it was understood that such association from childhood would lead to a better aptitude for medical learning and practice than one who is from non-medical family[1][2]

Two of the requirements, both connected with the morality of the student, may however be noticed in passing. These are:

  1. Brahmacarya
  2. Jitendriyatwa

Both are important qualities in the life of a student. A student is expected to be dedicated to the pursuit of knowledge and should therefore be able to turn his or her back on all sense-pleasures in the manner of the boy Naciketas, who when tempted by king Yama to give up his pursuit of the Truth said:

Keep thou thy chariots, thy dancing girls and singing; I will have none of them.

It is only then that the great king Yama considered him worthy of being taught, saying:

I know that you Naciketas, are a true seeker of knowledge, for you resisted all the temptations I put before you.

Conclusion

It is clear from the story in the Chandogya Upanisad that Brahmanas were given preferential treatment when it came to medical education. But in the course of time, Ksatriyas, Vaisyas and Sudras were admitted in increasing numbers[3]

References

  1. In support of this statement, Dr R. K Mookerjee says in his "Ancient Indian education" that Social psychology has proved that every individual has his own set of emotions, action attitudes and ways of thinking, which is the gift of the traditions and social environment in which he is brought up. Each segment of training must therefore take into account the concrete individuals, a product of biological gifts and social heritage. A neglect of this basic situation renders the process of education less fruitful and sometimes even more risky to the personality.
  2. The investigation of Haggerty, Nash and Goodenough show further that the educational status and vocation of the parents have a significant correlation with the level of capacity of the children as indicated by the intelligence quotient. For instance, the children of professional parents of those of a higher academic standing possess a higher value of I. Q on a whole.
  3. Susruta and Kashyapa Samhita denote that later on even the worthy and eligible Sudras were given admissions in the schools. where is this quote from?
    Some say that one should coach up even a Sudra possessed of good lineage and qualities withholding the instruction of Mantras and also the sacred thread.
  • The Caraka Samhita published by Shree Gulabkunverba Ayurvedic Society, Jamnagar, India